Barney's Pizza

4.5 (102 reviews )
$$
Pizza restaurant
Curbside pickup
Takeout
Dine-in
Breakfast
+(12)

About Barney's Pizza

Barney's Pizza, nestled at 218 W Morton Ave, Jacksonville, IL, is a beloved local gem renowned for its warm atmosphere and delicious offerings. Patrons rave about the thin crust pizza, but the menu extends well beyond with mouthwatering dishes like chicken cordon bleu and hearty tenderloins. The friendly staff creates a welcoming environment, taking the time to get to know regulars, adding to the personal dining experience. While occasional service delays may arise, the inviting ambience and delectable food make every visit worthwhile. Barney's is a must-visit for pizza lovers and those seeking a vibrant local eatery.

Reviews (102) 4.5

  • Megan Vant
    Jul 22,2025

    Love it here! Food is good and the servers are amazing! They take the time to get to know you when you come in regularly. They are very friendly even when they are busy!

  • Daniel Hoerchler
    Jul 22,2025

    Came in for dinner and some drinks, the chicken cordon Bleu was absolutely delicious. Miss Steph the bar tendress was awesome and very attentive. If you come to Jacksonville Illinois an don't have a drink and a good thin crust pie, it's your own fault. Absolutely amazing.

  • Mark Toland
    Jul 22,2025

    Food is awesome, but the management need to hire enough wait staff to actually serve the customers in a timely manner. The running joke in our house is “if you have 3 hours to kill we might as well go to Barney’s”

Frequently Asked Questions

  • What are some popular dishes at Barney's Pizza?

    Customers love the thin crust pizza and chicken cordon bleu, with many recommending the tenderloins and the unique "sweep the floor" pizza.

  • Do I need a reservation to dine at Barney's Pizza?

    While reservations are accepted, walk-ins are welcome, making it easy to stop by anytime for a meal.

  • Can I enjoy my meal on-site or only takeout?

    You can choose to dine in, take out, or enjoy curbside pickup, which offers flexibility depending on your mood.

  • What’s the atmosphere like at Barney's Pizza?

    The restaurant features a casual and cozy vibe, making it a great spot for solo dining, groups, or families, especially during lunch and dinner.

  • Is parking convenient at Barney's Pizza?

    While the parking lot isn’t the most convenient, there is free parking available both in the lot and on the street for your ease.

Nearby Pizza restaurants

Pizza restaurant
Cuban Pizzeria

4347 University Blvd S Jacksonville, FL 32216

Are you the owner?

Claim this page to update business information and manage your presence.

Claim this page Claim this page